Skip to main content

Most reliable toaster brands

Ranked by how often they last and get fixed, from real repair data.

Data from openrepair.org, and the French Repairability Index · 2,500 repairs · 11 brands · Last updated:

Bosch's your best bet for getting a toaster fixed. 61.5% success rate. Moulinex (52.8%) and Dualit (52%) come next, but there's a real gap.

Easiest to Fix

Bosch

61.5% fix rate

Longest Lasting

Tefal

12.9 years avg

Most Common Issue

Heating

Brands Tracked

11

Toaster Brand Rankings

1

Bosch

109 repair records · avg. 6.9 years old at repair

Fix rate

61.5%

Most common issues

Mechanical (11%)Heating (7.3%)Electrical (4.6%)Physical Damage (4.6%)Connectivity (2.8%)

Repair outcomes

Fixed 61%Repairable 6%End of life 33%

Top repair regions

GBR (38%)DEU (23%)BEL (18%)FRA (15%)ISR (6%)
2

Moulinex

125 repair records · avg. 12.6 years old at repair

Fix rate

52.8%

Most common issues

Physical Damage (4.8%)Electrical (2.4%)Audio (1.6%)Battery/Power (0.8%)Connectivity (0.8%)

Repair outcomes

Fixed 53%Repairable 7%End of life 40%

Top repair regions

FRA (71%)BEL (12%)ESP (8%)NLD (6%)DEU (4%)
3

Dualit

431 repair records · avg. 10.7 years old at repair

Fix rate

52%

Market price

$273

$/fix rate point

$5

Most common issues

Heating (28.3%)Electrical (8.1%)Physical Damage (7.9%)Mechanical (3.9%)Battery/Power (3.7%)

Repair outcomes

Fixed 52%Repairable 26%End of life 22%

Top repair regions

GBR (88%)NLD (4%)BEL (3%)DNK (3%)DEU (1%)
4

Tefal

220 repair records · avg. 12.9 years old at repair

Fix rate

51.4%

Most common issues

Heating (11.8%)Physical Damage (5.9%)Electrical (5%)Mechanical (3.6%)Audio (2.7%)

Repair outcomes

Fixed 51%Repairable 10%End of life 39%

Top repair regions

NLD (34%)GBR (27%)BEL (14%)FRA (13%)DEU (12%)
5

Breville

311 repair records · avg. 5.4 years old at repair

Fix rate

51.4%

Market price

$301

$/fix rate point

$6

Most common issues

Heating (13.8%)Mechanical (10.9%)Electrical (8.7%)Physical Damage (6.4%)Battery/Power (3.9%)

Repair outcomes

Fixed 51%Repairable 15%End of life 34%

Top repair regions

GBR (73%)NZL (15%)AUS (7%)CAN (5%)JEY (1%)

Market prices are median current listings for models from the last 5 years. $/Fix Pt = price ÷ fix rate - lower is better value.

Built to Last

Dualit

Classic NewGen 2-Slice Toaster

~$411
Durability
9/10
Repairability
10/10
Lifespan
20 yrs

Breville

A Bit More 4-Slice Toaster

~$297
Durability
7/10
Repairability
4/10
Lifespan
8 yrs

Krups

4-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster

~$213

Below 30-day avg

Durability
7/10
Repairability
6/10
Lifespan
8 yrs

We may earn a commission from purchases. Affiliate disclosure

Frequently Asked Questions

Brand Comparisons

Had a toaster break on you?

Help the next person facing the same decision. Your repair experience helps everyone make smarter choices.

Related Resources