Brother vs HP: Printer Reliability Compared
Which printer brand is more reliable? Side-by-side comparison based on 2,318 real repair records from community repair events.
Data from openrepair.org (CC BY-SA 4.0) · 5,000 total printer records
Last updated: · Fix rates refresh when openrepair.org publishes new data, about once a year
The Bottom Line
Brother has a slight repairability edge at 48.7% vs 39.9%, though both brands can typically be fixed when something goes wrong. Both brands show similar longevity, with printers typically coming in for repair around 7 years old. They break in different ways. Brother's most common issue is Electrical (10.4%), while HP mostly comes in for Mechanical (8.7%).
If durability matters most:
Brother has the repairability edge. When your printer eventually needs repair, Brother is more likely to be fixable. Both brands show similar longevity, so this advantage is the tiebreaker.
Based on 2,318 real repair records from community repair events. Scroll down for the full data breakdown.
Detailed Comparison
Head-to-head reliability data for Brother vs HP printers, based on 2,318 community repair records. Brother leads on fix rate (48.7% vs 39.9%).
| Metric | Brother | HP |
|---|---|---|
| Fix Rate | 48.7% | 39.9% |
| ValueCost per reliability point | $5.68/pt | $4.18/pt |
| Top Failure | Electrical (10.4%) | Mechanical (8.7%) |
| Sample Size | 520 | 1,798 |
| Typical Age at Repair | 7 years | 7 years |
Price Comparison
Like-for-like pricing across product tiers. Prices are approximate, in CAD.
Premium
No premium printer from HP
Value
No value printer from HP
As an Amazon Associate, Sundr earns from qualifying purchases.
Common Failure Types
Brother
HP
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Brother or HP more reliable for printers?
Based on 2,318 repair records, Brother is more reliable with a 48.7% fix rate vs 39.9% for HP.
What are the most common Brother vs HP printer failures?
Brother's top issues are electrical and mechanical. HP's top issues are mechanical and electrical.
Which printer brand lasts longer, Brother or HP?
Both brands show similar longevity: their devices are typically around 7 years old when they come in for repair.
Should I buy Brother or HP if durability matters?
If durability is your priority, Brother edges ahead with a higher fix rate, meaning repairs are more likely to succeed when needed. The best choice still depends on your specific model and usage.