Our Pick: iPhone 17 Pro
If you want the phone most likely to survive daily life without a case, the iPhone 17 Pro is our pick. Ceramic Shield 2 on front and back is the best glass protection available on any phone right now. In Allstate's drop tests, the back survived a 6-foot concrete drop with only cosmetic scuffs, something no other phone managed. The 7000-series aluminum frame bent at 200 lbs, the IP68 rating covers submersion to 6 meters, and Apple's 7+ year software track record is the most proven in the industry.
The catch: the camera plateau edges chip and scratch easily ("Scratchgate"), which is a cosmetic annoyance. And Apple's repair ecosystem is expensive. But for raw physical durability, the glass is what matters most, and Apple's is the best.
If repairability matters more to you than sheer toughness, the Fairphone 5 is the better long-term investment. Everything is user-replaceable, the 5-year warranty is unmatched, and 8+ years of software support means you'll be using it long after other phones have been recycled.
Durability at a Glance
| Spec | Fairphone 5 | iPhone 17 Pro | Galaxy S25 Ultra | Pixel 9 Pro |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IP rating | IP55 | IP68 (6m) | IP68 (1.5m) | IP68 (1.5m) |